Personal Property Appraisal

Insurance & Replacement Value — USPAP-compliant insurance scheduling appraisals prepared for submission to high-value-individual carriers and their brokers, replacement value reports for fine jewelry, watches, art, and collectibles, damage and diminution-of-value reports for insurance claims, and loss settlement support.

Estate, Probate & Divorce — Date-of-death fair market value appraisals for U.S. estate matters, Canadian deemed-disposition reports establishing CRA fair market value at death, probate inventory valuations, equitable distribution appraisals for matrimonial proceedings, and bankruptcy estate valuations.

IRS & Tax Authority — IRS Form 8283 qualified appraisals for charitable contributions over $5,000, IRS Form 706 estate tax appraisals, valuation support in tax controversy and audit matters, and second-opinion review of prior appraisal reports. Qualified appraiser under 26 CFR §1.170A-17(b)(2)(i)(A) via Path A (coursework and experience). U.S. persons living abroad: see expat appraisals; non-resident estates with U.S.-situs property: see Form 706-NA appraisals.

Authentication & Forensic Reports — Written authentication letters on PROVENANCE letterhead for resale-platform disputes, private transactions, and litigation, forensic authentication reports for attorney use, provenance research, counterfeit determination opinions, and expert opinions for customs and consumer-protection matters.

Pre-Sale & Advisory — Pre-sale auction estimates, consignment advisory, fair market value opinions for private-sale due diligence, acquisition support for collectors, and resale strategy consultation.

U.S. Citizens & Green-Card Holders Abroad — Form 8283 charitable donation, Form 706 estate tax, and gift reporting appraisals for U.S. persons living anywhere in the world. Fully remote.

U.S. Estate Tax for Non-Residents (Form 706-NA) — Fair market value appraisals of U.S.-situs tangible personal property for non-resident estates.

Canadian Departure Tax & Deemed Disposition — CRA fair market value appraisals for emigration and at death, including retrospective effective dates.

Insurance Appraisals — Replacement-value scheduling documentation for carriers and brokers, remote and worldwide.

Insurance Loss & Theft Claims — Valuations of stolen, destroyed, or damaged items reconstructed from documentation, as of the date of loss, for claims and the disputes that follow.

Divorce & Family Law Appraisals — Retrospective fair market value appraisals for property division.

Appraisal Review & Rebuttal Reports — Independent review under USPAP Standards 3 and 4.

CBP Detention & Seizure Reports — Authenticity examination and value of the genuine article for goods detained or seized by U.S. Customs and Border Protection.

Luxury Handbags & Goods — Coverage across 50+ houses, with deep brand-specific expertise in:

Fine Jewelry & Watches — Engagement rings and high jewelry, signed and designer pieces, vintage and antique jewelry, Rolex, Cartier, Patek Philippe, Audemars Piguet, and other Swiss watches. Diamond characteristics are taken from existing GIA, AGS, or equivalent laboratory grading reports supplied by the client.

Fine Art — Group of Seven and Canadian historical art (Lawren Harris, Tom Thomson, A.Y. Jackson, Frederick Varley, J.E.H. MacDonald, and others), Canadian post-war and contemporary, with broader coverage of European and American works dependent on engagement scope.

Collectibles & Alternative Assets — Classic and collector cars, fine wine and spirits, vintage workwear and heritage clothing, sports and entertainment memorabilia, design objects, and pieces with Christie's and Sotheby's provenance.

USPAP Standards 7 & 8 — Every appraisal report is prepared in conformity with the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice, Standards 7 (Personal Property Appraisal Development) and 8 (Personal Property Appraisal Reporting), as developed by the Appraisal Standards Board of the Appraisal Foundation. Each report documents intended use, intended users, type and definition of value, scope of work, identification of the subject property, market analysis, valuation approach, and appraiser certification.

Standards of Value — Fair market value (per Treas. Reg. §1.170A-1(c)(2) and CRA equivalents) for estate, donation, equitable distribution, and tax purposes; replacement value for insurance scheduling; orderly liquidation value where the engagement requires it. The applicable standard is established in the engagement letter and clearly stated in the report.

Comparable Sales Research — Valuations are grounded in documented comparable sales drawn from primary auction data (Heritage Auctions, Sotheby's, Christie's, Bonhams, Phillips, Heffel, and Cowley Abbott), licensed databases, and direct dealer-market research. All comparable sales are documented in the report for verifiability.

Fee Structure — Single-piece USPAP-compliant insurance and fair market value reports are available at flat rates, quoted on request. The appraisal practice is a distinct, non-litigation service line; expert witness and litigation engagements are quoted separately under the expert witness fee schedule. Multi-piece, IRS Form 8283, IRS Form 706, estate, divorce, and Canadian deemed-disposition engagements are quoted by engagement letter based on scope of work, time, and complexity. Fees are never contingent on appraised value, never percentage-based. For charitable contribution appraisals, contingent fees are prohibited by 26 CFR §1.170A-17(a)(9); as a matter of professional practice, contingent fees are not used for any appraisal engagement.

Confidentiality — All client information, property details, and appraisal results are held confidentially per USPAP Ethics Rule (Confidentiality). Disclosure occurs only as required by law, regulation, or with client authorization, and the engagement letter documents the parties to whom disclosure is permitted.

Education — Honours BA, University of Toronto, with additional studies at the University of Oxford. USPAP-compliant via Personal Property coursework through the International Society of Appraisers (ISA), per Appraisal Standards Board requirements.

Experience — Over 10 years of professional experience valuing luxury goods, fine jewelry, art, and collectibles through PROVENANCE, with more than 2,000,000 items examined across 50+ brands. Founding Director of PROVENANCE (luxury authentication, appraisal, and advisory practice). Published author of Provenance: The Business of Authenticating Luxury.

Qualified Appraiser Status — Qualified appraiser under 26 CFR §1.170A-17(b)(2)(i)(A), satisfying the Path A education and experience requirement (successfully completed coursework in valuing the type of property plus more than two years of experience valuing the type of property). Each Form 8283 or Form 706 engagement includes the §1.170A-17(b)(4) declaration affirming qualification for the specific type of property being appraised.

Expert Witness Practice — Expert witness for U.S. and Canadian litigation; full expert witness practice and engagement details on the expert witness practice page.

Are you a qualified appraiser for IRS purposes?

Yes. Under 26 CFR §1.170A-17(b)(2)(i)(A), a qualified appraiser is one who has successfully completed coursework in valuing the type of property and has two or more years of experience in valuing the type of property. USPAP-compliant via Personal Property coursework through the International Society of Appraisers (ISA), plus over a decade of professional experience valuing luxury goods, jewelry, art, and collectibles through PROVENANCE — with more than 2 million items examined across 50+ brands — satisfies the Path A standard.

How long does an appraisal take?

Timelines depend on the scope of the engagement — the number of items, the state of documentation, and the intended use of the report — and are confirmed in the engagement letter before work begins.

Can you appraise from photographs?

Yes for many property types, particularly when supported by existing laboratory certificates (such as GIA grading reports for diamonds), provenance documents, receipts, and clear photographs of all relevant features and hallmarks. Engagements are documentation-driven and conducted remotely; where counsel or a filing position requires physical examination, that is addressed by written agreement before the engagement begins. The scope of work is documented in the appraisal report per USPAP requirements.

What's the difference between insurance value and fair market value?

Insurance replacement value reflects the cost to replace the item with one of like kind and quality at retail, used for insurance scheduling. Fair market value is the price at which the property would change hands between a willing buyer and willing seller, used for estate, divorce, charitable donation, and tax purposes. The two values can differ substantially. The applicable standard of value is stated in each engagement letter and report.

Do you charge contingent fees?

No. Appraisal fees are based on scope of work, time, and complexity. Contingent fees based on appraised value are prohibited for charitable contribution appraisals under 26 CFR §1.170A-17(a)(9), and as a matter of professional practice are not used for any engagement.

Are you available outside Toronto?

Yes. Available for matters in all U.S. and Canadian jurisdictions. Appraisals are remote and documentation-driven and are available everywhere. Where an engagement requires physical examination or in-person testimony, that is addressed by written agreement, with travel billed separately.

How do I engage you for an appraisal?

Send a message via the contact form below describing the property, the intended use of the appraisal (insurance, estate, divorce, donation, etc.), and any deadlines. An engagement letter and fee estimate will be provided before any work commences. The engagement letter documents scope of work, intended users, intended use, type of value, and appraiser qualifications per USPAP Standards 7 and 8.

Do you also handle expert witness work?

Yes. Expert witness practice — including testimony, depositions, and court submissions — is detailed on the expert witness practice page. Many appraisal engagements include or are followed by expert witness components; both can be coordinated, with each scope and fee basis documented in its engagement letter.