Jack Holowczak — personal property appraiser, Toronto

Canadian Departure Tax & Deemed Disposition Appraisals

USPAP-Compliant · Personal Property · U.S. & Canada

When a Canadian resident emigrates — to the United States, the United Kingdom, Australia, the Gulf, or anywhere else — the Income Tax Act generally deems most capital property to have been disposed of at fair market value on the date of departure. The same deemed-disposition logic applies at death. Both events turn a collection — art, jewellery, watches, handbags, rare books — into a valuation question.

The practice prepares USPAP-compliant fair market value appraisals supporting the values reported to the CRA, on a remote, documentation-driven basis, for clients still in Canada and clients who have already left.

Common engagements include valuing a watch, art, or handbag collection as of a departure date — before or after the move.

Services

Emigration. Ceasing Canadian residence generally triggers a deemed disposition at fair market value of most capital property, including personal-use property and listed personal property such as art and jewellery, with certain categories excluded (for example, Canadian real property). Reporting can also include listing property held at departure where CRA thresholds are met (Form T1161). Which rules apply to a given departure is a question for your tax advisor — the appraisal establishes and documents the fair market values those filings rely on.
Deemed Disposition at Death. Capital property is generally deemed disposed of at fair market value immediately before death. Estates and executors engage the practice to support reported values with defensible appraisal documentation.
What the Report Provides. Fair market value at the effective date — including retrospective effective dates — developed from comparable sales in primary auction records and licensed databases, in a USPAP Standards 7 and 8 report stating the standard of value, scope of work, and assumptions.
Fees. Quoted by engagement letter based on scope of work, time, and complexity; never contingent on appraised value.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which personal items are caught by departure tax?

Emigration generally deems most capital property disposed of at fair market value, including categories of personal-use and listed personal property; thresholds and exclusions apply. Your tax advisor determines what must be reported — the appraisal documents the values.

I have already left Canada. Can values still be established?

Yes. Retrospective effective dates are standard appraisal practice: fair market value is developed as of the departure date from market evidence for that date.

Can this be done remotely?

Yes. The methodology is documentation-driven — photographs, receipts, provenance records, and comparable-sales analysis — and engagements are conducted asynchronously and in writing.

I am moving to the United States. Do you handle both sides?

Cross-border moves can raise both CRA and U.S. valuation questions. The practice prepares reports for both regimes — see the U.S. expat appraisal page — with your advisors determining the filings each report supports.

How much does a tax appraisal cost?

Engagements are quoted by engagement letter based on scope of work, time, and complexity — the number of items, the state of documentation, and the intended use of the report. Fees are never contingent on appraised value.

Which items must be listed on Form T1161?

Form T1161 lists property held on the date of emigration where the total fair market value of reportable property exceeds $25,000. Items of personal-use property worth less than $10,000 are generally excluded from the listing. Which items are reportable in a given departure — and which gains are reported on the related deemed-disposition schedule — is determined by your tax advisor; the appraisal establishes and documents the fair market values those forms rely on.

Engage Appraisal Services